Moral judgments are decisions, not conclusions Decisions ought to be made situationally, not prescriptively We should seek the well-being of people, rather than love principles. Proportionalists believe there are certain moral rules which one should not let go of unless there is a proportionate reason for doing so and this would be grounded in the particular situation.
Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. What Fletcher attempted to do was to create a compromise between having too many rules and no rules at all.
As the name situation ethics suggests, for Fletcher, it is the situation that is important for determining what should be done. Those concerned that Situation Ethics went too far in its desire to be free from any notion of Law have required to develop amore balanced approach through what is known as Proportionalism.
Fletcher argued that the two extremes of antinomianism and legalism cannot work, ant that he only truly capable ethical standard is the middle course of love. From the Bible Leviticus Agape does not depend on being loved in return. We do not know if our actions will lead to heartache or joy but the promotion of love for the Situationist requires us to do so if we are to avoid acting selfishly, for example if a 16 year old girl should have an abortion because it is believed she will not be a responsible mother, we do not know based on her present age and actions whether she will hold her responsibility and be a great mother to her child or struggle to take on this huge responsibility, and this is only something that time would be able to tell.
Is one rule too general? Instead of a whole number of rules, Fletcher suggested that there is only one rule that everyone should follow.
Elements of situation ethics The elements of situation ethics were described by Joseph Fletcher, its leading modern proponent, like this: The traditional Christian view is whatever God does is love and essentially humans should try to follow this.
For example, lying is ordinarily not in the best interest of interpersonal communication and social integrity, but is justifiable nevertheless in certain situations. Finally, by what criteria is the Situationist able to make moral decisions?
Situation Ethics has been criticised on a number of important points. Probably the most famous set of rules is the 10 Commandments. There are no universal moral rules or rights - each case is unique and deserves a unique solution. Each situation therefore is best assessed and acted upon in terms of the best consequences to be brought out by love and love alone.
Only one thing is intrinsically good, namely, love: Another criticism is what about God? Fletcher defines what people should do in terms of love: It has been argued that Fletcher does not really give any real instructions about what morally ought to be done.
Christian love is not based on desire; it is self-giving love or agape.Explain What Is Meant By Situation Ethics Essay Sample. Religion has for a long time been a source of moral rules for many people. Probably the most famous set of rules is the 10 Commandments.
Situation ethics is an ethical theory pioneered by Joseph Fletcher in the 's, a time in which society and the church were facing drastic change.
It is an idealistic, teleological, consequentialist theory that resolves ethical and moral issues relative to the situation. In situation ethics his view was to look at each situation individually.
His main line of argument was that the only moral principle that could be applied to all situations is that of love, or: ‘To do whatever is the most loving thing.’ (Fletcher quoted by.
Examine the Key Ideas of Situation Ethics (21 Marks) In this essay, I am going to examine the key features of Situation Ethics. Situation Ethics is a teleological theory that resolves ethical and moral issues relative to the situation and was developed at a time when society and the church were facing drastic and permanent change.
I. Examine the strengths and weaknesses of Situation Ethics. (21) May Situation Ethics is a teleological theory which takes a relativist approach by doing the most loving thing according to the situation and the predicted consequence regardless of laws and.
Oct 14, · Situation ethics teaches that ethical decisions should follow flexible guidelines rather than absolute rules, and be taken on a case by case basis.Download